such-heights:

So I have Feelings about this (no one is surprised). My primary feeling being yes good excellent - River’s queerness has been hinted at in canon but not strongly, so Word of God confirmation is pleasing to see. In general wrt to Moffat’s conversations on twitter about queerness in Doctor Who I feel like I want to send him some suggested reading or something so he can reframe what he’s saying in some ways, because once an academic always an academic, apparently. But twitter’s a lousy forum for these kinds of conversations and I grok what he’s getting at, that the world of Doctor Who is one in which current categories of sexuality as we understand it prove to be transient things that won’t matter so much in the future, and I like that a lot. Your mileage may vary, I do not speak for all queer Who fans, etc.

Anyway. Take-home point: River Song, definitely canonically into the ladies. <3

Yusss - like this is great (CANONICALLY BI RIVER YES. GOOD. THANK YOU.) but I really wish Moffat understood what he was talking about a LEETLE bit better. He strikes me as someone with basically the right intentions wrt women and queers, but very, very poor execution both in  his writing and in the way he frames his sentiments online. And given how much power he has, culturally, to shape certain narratives through his work, that isn’t really good enough. He’s in a position of responsibility, and if he wants to play with queer characters he has a duty to educate himself the same way I do when I write about a marginalised group who I don’t belong to. 

steven moffat the personal is political the politics of representation those really misogynist statements of his would be a LOT easier to get away from (given that they WERE taken really out of context) if he generated actual willing to educate himself on the issues at hand rather than flapping about assuming that because he's The Moff he no longer needs to push himself and because his INTENTIONS are good he can't be faulted no steven - steven no
Caption:

such-heights:

So I have Feelings about this (no one is surprised). My primary feeling being yes good excellent - River’s queerness has been hinted at in canon but not strongly, so Word of God confirmation is pleasing to see. In general wrt to Moffat’s conversations on twitter about queerness in Doctor Who I feel like I want to send him some suggested reading or something so he can reframe what he’s saying in some ways, because once an academic always an academic, apparently. But twitter’s a lousy forum for these kinds of conversations and I grok what he’s getting at, that the world of Doctor Who is one in which current categories of sexuality as we understand it prove to be transient things that won’t matter so much in the future, and I like that a lot. Your mileage may vary, I do not speak for all queer Who fans, etc.

Anyway. Take-home point: River Song, definitely canonically into the ladies. <3

Yusss - like this is great (CANONICALLY BI RIVER YES. GOOD. THANK YOU.) but I really wish Moffat understood what he was talking about a LEETLE bit better. He strikes me as someone with basically the right intentions wrt women and queers, but very, very poor execution both in  his writing and in the way he frames his sentiments online. And given how much power he has, culturally, to shape certain narratives through his work, that isn’t really good enough. He’s in a position of responsibility, and if he wants to play with queer characters he has a duty to educate himself the same way I do when I write about a marginalised group who I don’t belong to. 



Posted 2 years ago at 03:01pm with 4,497 notes
Tagged as: #steven moffat #the personal is political #the politics of representation #those really misogynist statements of his would be a LOT easier to get away from #(given that they WERE taken really out of context) #if he generated actual willing to educate himself on the issues at hand #rather than flapping about assuming that because he's The Moff he no longer needs to push himself #and because his INTENTIONS are good he can't be faulted #no steven - steven #no

  1. alwaysbringabanana2aparty reblogged this from sweettasteofbitter
  2. tu-verras-on-va-voir reblogged this from freerangeraspberries
  3. soclosetocanon reblogged this from d-o-r-ia-n
  4. lord-of-the-onion-ring reblogged this from jaylacucu
  5. asmidgeofexcitement reblogged this from jaylacucu and added:
    JACK IS OMNISEXUAL OH MY GOD
  6. jaylacucu reblogged this from confessions-of-a-gallifreyan
  7. werenotsupossedtotalkaboutit reblogged this from notawishgrantingblog
  8. oh-my-squash reblogged this from uhohcicero
  9. ever-so-absolutely-boring reblogged this from castielcampbell
  10. uhohcicero reblogged this from carrots-and-cauliflower
  11. darrenwolf1128 reblogged this from carrots-and-cauliflower
  12. carrots-and-cauliflower reblogged this from just-call-me-sweettart
  13. just-call-me-sweettart reblogged this from deductiom
  14. lucifers-little-sis reblogged this from deductiom
  15. mypenguinisaninja reblogged this from mageletofpiratesswoop
  16. grantaires-drinking-buddy reblogged this from deductiom
  17. no-longer-a-fallen-angel reblogged this from deducing-a-pancake
  18. deductiom reblogged this from deducing-a-pancake
  19. glowtardis reblogged this from deducing-a-pancake
  20. deducing-a-pancake reblogged this from daleksempire
  21. suephay reblogged this from confessions-of-a-gallifreyan
  22. caledoniarose reblogged this from castielcampbell
  23. asphodelethe reblogged this from castielcampbell
  24. maladaptivemischief reblogged this from audiovisualrecall
  25. consultingangeldoctor reblogged this from yes-you-can-touch-my-butt
  26. of-mice-and-winchester reblogged this from fangirling-fixes-everything
  27. fangirling-fixes-everything reblogged this from thatweasleykid1
  28. ohfxxkitsme reblogged this from claraception
  29. touchm3withthesloth reblogged this from daleksempire
  30. awesomecatflaps reblogged this from castielcampbell
  31. oldeststoryintheuniverse reblogged this from thebasiliskfang
  32. thebasiliskfang reblogged this from castielcampbell
  33. offinthetardis reblogged this from castielcampbell